Though it’s tempting – not to mention incredibly satisfying – to pump your mascara, don’t. This causes it to dry out fast, as it allows air into the formula.

Additionally, you shouldn’t be afraid to use more than one mascara to achieve your desired look. Gene adds, “Apply a lengthening mascara first, then allow it to dry, and then follow with a mascara that focuses more on volume to add shape to the lashes.” What Are the Differences Between Mascara Wands? verifyErrors }}{{ message }}{{ /verifyErrors }}{{ Henney, too, is particular about wands, as they can help with separating, curling, and lengthening the lashes. Personally, “I love wands with tiny spikes to help with a very defined, separated lash,” she says. Meet The Experts Before you spend hours perusing through the makeup aisle in search of the perfect mascara, don't worry— Marie Claire editors beat you to it. We’ve tried just about every mascara from every price point to come up with the best of the best.

7 ways to get the most out of your mascara

Keita Moore is a celebrity makeup artist whose clients include Yara Shahidi, Janelle Monae, Iman, and more Anthony Nguyen is a celebrity makeup artist whose clientele includes Adele, Sydney Sweeney, and Camila Cabello Vincent Oquendo is a celebrity makeup artist, whose client roster includes Jenna Ortega, Lily Collins, and Hailey Bieber Love the wand but interested in trying out another formula? You can always save the wand and use it with other mascaras. Just make sure to clean it first with eye make-up remover.

Extend your mascara’s lifespan by adding a few pipettes of a trusted eye drop to the formula whenever it begins to get dry or clumpy.

The verdict: Waterproof mascaras