I’m not too acquainted with the Maybelline Color Sensational lip liners; I’ve only used a couple so far.

I’ve got a few good alternatives here for you, from Morphe to Golden Rose, and from NYX to Colourpop! I don’t see a point in showing you makeup brands that don’t carry the dupe anymore, so hopefully, you’ll find what you need here! To be honest, I’ve always loved the Kiko Smart Fusion lip liners better, simply because the range is utterly huge. This is not an exact dupe, however, you do have that same slight grey undertone that makes the MAC Oak lip liner so unmistakable.

I’m much more acquainted with British drugstore makeup brands like MUA or Barry M (by the way, there are plenty of MAC lip liner dupes from Barry M, from Soar to Whirl and Cherry!). Actually, the most perfect NYX dupe for MAC Oak I’ve found is in the shade Munchies, but from my understanding, it’s been discontinued. It glides on the lips super easily, and the finish is completely matte, which means you can wear it on its own too. Those guides range from Kiko products to beautiful NYX Slim lip liner dupes for MAC, and many other still-underrated brands.

And well, roughly the same thing happened when Kylie Jenner talked about using the MAC Soar lip liner– it sold out. Let’s talk a little bit about all the best MAC Oak lip liner dupes today, since it’s clearly one of the most famous MAC lip liners this year! Another really cool MAC Oak lip liner dupe is the Maybelline Color Sensational lip liner in 105 Nude Whisper. To the best of my understanding and after much research, these are currently the best MAC Oak lip liner dupes… And actually, I did start this full guide series with a post about MAC Velvet Teddy dupes, in which you can find many beloved drugstore brands.The real upside of the Maybelline Color Sensational lip liners is how precise they are, which means you lose no product, and can draw those crisp lines in one go.

The Golden Rose lip liner in 223 is smooth, glides really well, and is overall creamier than the MAC Oak lip liner while providing almost the same shade, albeit a tad lighter.This is where the pros come in, as they're the ones who work with lip liner on clients every day and have a wellspring of knowledge when it comes to what neutral shades work best on each skin tone. Most of you are probably already makeup-savvy enough to know that someone with fair or light skin wouldn't want to wear the same shades as someone with a tan or dark complexion, but even still, it can be super-helpful to hear from experts because you can count on their recommendations being some of the best out there. They were some of my first lip liners ever, when I started out in makeup and actually, one of the best MAC Oak lip liner dupes is the Golden Rose lip liner in 223. The Suede Matte lip liner in Sandstorm is slightly darker than Oak, with a bit more of a warm undertone to it.

Although it is one of the best MAC lip liners for fair skin and pale skin, it just seems that shades like Stripdown, Spice and Whirl are much more coveted.However, if you’re looking for a good MAC Oak lip liner dupe, you will find the closest one in the Everlasting Colour Precision Lip Liner range in the shade 402.