Collect your ingredients. For this method, you’ll need a 1/2 cup of white glue. Elmer’s glue is the go-to here or any other white school glue. You'll also need about 1 teaspoon of brown paint or brown food coloring, 1/2 a cup of warm water, and 1 teaspoon of borax powder. You’ll need two containers for mixing, at least one of which is fairly large for the final mix. [5] X Research source Gather the ingredients. For this method, you’ll need 1.5 cups of powdered sugar, ⅓ cup of peanut butter, ⅓ cup of cocoa powder, and 1 tablespoon milk. You won’t need any cooking supplies besides a large bowl in which to mix the ingredients. The ingredients will form a dough that you mold into fake poop. [1] X Research source The peanut butter you use can be creamy or chunky. Chunky peanut butter can add a little texture to the eventual product.

Submerge the paper roll. Take the now open cardboard roll and push it to the bottom of the bowl of water. You’ll most likely need to hold it at the bottom with your hand. Allow a minute or so for the cardboard roll to fill with water. Once soaked, it will be pliable and capable of molding into your fake poop. Once both individual mixes are complete, combine them in the larger bowl, stirring constantly as you do so. Open the cardboard roll. On your toilet paper roll, you should see that it is formed by a spiral glued to itself. Generally, the ends of the spiral will be pointed tips at either end of the toilet paper roll. The cardboard should be soft enough that you can rip it yourself, undoing the glue and unfurling the paper roll into a cardboard sheet. [3] X Research source verifyErrors }}{{ message }}{{ /verifyErrors }}{{ If you have neither brown paint or brown food coloring, use chocolate syrup. You will need a slightly higher amount of chocolate syrup than you would brown paint or food coloring. Combine your ingredients. First, in the large bowl, (which will eventually contain the entire mix), combine the 1/2 cup of white glue and whatever you’re using as brown coloring. Add color until you have your desired hue. In another container, mix your borax and water until the borax is visibly dissolved. Mold your fake poop. Remove the cardboard from the water. You may need to hold it above the bowl for a few seconds to allow the excess water to fall off. The cardboard is best molded by laying it flat in your hand and squeezing into a closed fist. This will compress the cardboard into your fake poop. [4] X Research source